[URBANTH-L]RE: UNITE HERE Statement
William_Beeman at brown.edu
Fri Oct 29 19:12:59 EDT 2004
Please understand that I am speaking as an individual AAA board member, and not for the board as a whole.
I appreciate the letter from UNITE--especially its cooperative tone, and recognition of the practical realities faced by the AAA in scheduling its meetings. but the August 30 date for the union contacting the AAA mentioned in the letter is most certainly inaccurate. Moreover the AAA board was not alerted to the issue until the 14-15th of October. The first discussion we had together was October 21. With regard to changing the meeting venue, the AAA staff in Virginia could not have acted without the Board's approval. I believe Bill Davis, our executive director, will be issuing a formal statement on this.
I believe I am correct in saying that AAA board has every intention of working with the unions to insure that this situation does not arise in the future. The suggestions that force majeure clauses be included in future contracts is absolutely on our agenda, as well as other guarantees that will protect our membership from having to undermine the efforts of the unions to secure a fair and equitable working contract for their members. Moreover, I believe we all understand that working with other scholarly organizations to use our influence with hotel chains for the greater good is in our collective best interest; I for one will actively pursue this.
The board has been riddled with frustration at the conflicting restrictions we were under in making a decision on this matter this year. We realized with a sinking feeling that whatever we chose to do, some group would be dissatisfied. We only hope that the AAA as a whole can come together again to plan for a better set of future policies to prevent the further compromise of our professional goals--both in furthering anthropological knowledge, and behaving collectively as ethical and responsible members of society. Ideally this test of our organization will be an institutional learning experience as so many other tests in our past have been. With the good will of our colleagues, it should strengthen us for the future. With everyone's help, we will come through this and be better for it.
William O. Beeman
Professor, Anthropology; and Theatre, Speech and Dance
Providence, RI 02912
Tel: (401) 863-3251
(2004-2005 Visiting Professor, Cultural and Social Anthropology,
Stanford University, Stanford, CA 94305)
From: Robert T. O'Brien [mailto:robrien at temple.edu]
Sent: Thu 10/28/2004 11:01 PM
To: Angrad; H-Medanthro; Urbananth-l; nmd at u.arizona.edu; Samuel.martinez at uconn.edu; kgw at azstarnet.com; mjacquemet at usfca.edu; dlnugent at colby.edu; dvalenti at mail.slc.edu; clbriggs at weber.ucsd.edu; laura-graham at uiowa.edu; apyburn at indiana.edu; galema1L at aol.com; cfluehr at grog.ric.edu; martink at fiu.edu; larry-zimmerman at uiowa.edu; rcaspari at umich.edu; aspring at ufl.edu; LSilvers at aol.com; crodrigu at chuma1.cas.usf.edu; rrotenbe at depaul.edu; greenbau at chuma1.cas.usf.edu; fghanna1 at swarthmore.edu; nancy.foner at purchase.edu; lawinski at rcn.com; Bridgman at cc.umanitoba.ca; tboellst at uci.edu; christine.pettett at yale.edu; ctw at usc.edu; rudolf.gaudio at purchase.edu; ellen-lewin at uiowa.edu; anthrocubsf at aol.com; dlrh at uvm.edu; christa.craven at verizon.net; nakamura at macalaster.edu; wlm at american.edu; morgansen at macalester.edu; kacurtis at udel.edu; kmfoster at siu.edu; bsr2008 at columbia.edu; mbaltoda at lmu.edu; C&A at utsa.edu; president at practicinganthropology.org; studentrep at practicinganthropology.org; chadmorris1 at aol.com; fmannix at tulane.edu; kboswell at indiana.edu; heffera2 at msu.edu; siddhartha1972 at hotmail.com; mlm2004 at columbia.edu; burciuol at hamilton.edu; pstrong at mail.utexas.edu; rftr at uhura.cc.rochester.edu; anagnost at u.washington.edu; alonso at email.arizona.edu; mdelac at ucdavis.edu; mfischer at mit.edu; lrofel at cats.ucsc.edu; lmille2 at luc.edu; yan at anthro.ucla.edu; bestor at wjh.harvard.edu; maclelln at gol.com; psong at fas.harvard.edu; blimmichael at hotmail.com; frothstein at towson.edu; smart at ucalgary.ca; griffithd at mail.ecu.edu; jweil at smm.org; alee at jjay.cuny.edu; hannalessigner at cs.com; ssimon at uottawa.ca; claw158 at juno.com; slyon at learnlink.emory.edu; etgordon at mail.utexas.edu; pbuck00 at pop.uky.edu; mcclauri at anthro.ufl.edu; LDBaker at Duke.Edu; cemihovich at coe.ufl.edu; Katieal at umd.umich.edu; Hamann, Edmund; kathleen at coe.uga.edu; tmccarty at u.arizona.edu; Braybo_b at ed.utah.edu; svillenas at mail.utexas.edu; ymajors at uic.edu; jhecsh at csus.edu; oaks at womst.ucsb.edu; dana-ain.davis at purchase.edu; hkelley at unca.edu; jesscatt at uchicago.edu; wiedmand at fiu.edu; agoodman at hampshire.edu; mac-marshall at uiowa.edu; crumley at unc.edu; wolfel at email.ecu.edu; jgonzalez42 at earthlink.net; gaclark at asu.edu; jti at umich.edu; Lbennett at memphis.edu; wileyas at jmu.edu; dsegal at hal.pitzer.edu; marcus at rice.edu; Beeman, William; Alisse Waterston; Ana Aparicio; Angrad; Carol Nagengast; Christine Gailey; Craig Janes; Donald Nonini; Gary Kalman; Jay Sokolovsky; Jeffry Maskovsky; Judith Farquhar; Judy Goode; June Nash; Karen Brodkin; Maria Vesperi; Mary Anglin; Merrill Singer; Molly Doane; PAUL DURRENBERGER; Paul Farmer; Paule Cruz Takash; Sam Beck; Sue ESTROFF; Susan Hyatt; Tim Sieber; Vincent Lyon-Callo
Cc: ebrumfiel at northwestern.edu; Lutz, Catherine; isusser at hunter.cuny.edu; rlitz at Duke.Edu; guster at mit.edu; g.fraser at fordfound.org; kmgeorge at facstaff.wisc.edu; yangm at anth.ucsb.edu; bunzl at uiuc.edu; aaf19 at columbia.edu; lh206 at nyu.edu; manglin at uky.edu; florence-babb at uiowa.edu; pstone at wmich.edu; Cheryl.B.Mwaria at Hofstra.edu; dhodgson at rci.rutgers.edu; rajoyce at uclink.berkeley.edu; megan.sinnott at colorado.edu; suzbaker at umd.umich.edu; sterling at sscl.berkeley.edu; Dmartin at hampshire.edu; nandini at ucla.edu; aejournal at uiowa.edu
Subject: UNITE HERE Statement
Please see the forwarded message below. Neal Kwatra form
UNITE HERE has emailed this message to Alan Goodman and
several others who have been working with the union.
---- Original message ----
>Date: Thu, 28 Oct 2004 19:40:30 -0400
>From: "Neal Kwatra" <nkwatra at hereunion.org>
>To: agoodman at hampshire.edu, Paulect69 at aol.com,
robrien at temple.edu, epd2 at psu.edu, kathryn.clancy at yale.edu,
borofsky at hpu.edu
>Cc: nkwatra at hereunion.org, nkwatra at igc.org
>I am Neal Kwatra, a coordinator in the Strategic Affairs
>Department with UNITE HERE, the Union that represents the
>locked out workers in San Francisco.
>Leaders and members of the AAA have asked me to address
>some of the issues your organization has been debating
>over the last week.
>We sincerely appreciate the AAA for not crossing the
>picket line and moving the convention out of San
>Francisco, however, we would have preferred a different
>outcome than the contract swap with Hilton in Atlanta.
>Thank you for all your hard work on this issue, our
>members in San Francisco and throughout the country truly
>appreciate your support and solidarity. The best way to
>support our locked out members in this struggle and
>long-term, is to work with us and other organizations on a
>long-term program to level the playing field between
>multinational hotel corporations and their workers.
>The link below will give you an opportunity to better
>understand the issues our members are so courageously
>fighting for in San Francisco.
>I think it is important to provide you with some of the
>history of our efforts to arrive at a solution that would
>work for the AAA, its members and for the thousands of
>locked out hotel workers on the streets in San Francisco,
>who are without livelihood for the duration of the
>Our Union initially reached out to the AAA on August 30.
>We offered to work with your organization on alternative
>locations that would be of minimal disruption (San Jose).
> Because we have experience working with other groups, in
>the context of labor disputes, we offered to work with
>your staff on the liability issues as well. We offered to
>work in partnership to come up with a mutually beneficial
>situation for the AAA and our members in San Francisco.
>Unfortunately, we were never able to advance the
>conversation with your staff.
>The first time anyone in the leadership or staff of the
>AAA reached out to our Union to discuss this situation was
>early last week when I received a call from
>President-elect Alan Goodman. He was very clear that his
>goal was to work with UNITE HERE in a constructive fashion
>to support our locked out members in SF, while
>simultaneously finding a viable solution for the AAA.
>Despite good-faith efforts on his part to explore mutually
>beneficial options like San Jose, another school of
>thought prevailed. Alan Goodman has been a helpful partner
>in our collective efforts to support the locked out
>workers in SF and I look forward to working with him and
>others within the AAA as the struggle for hotel worker
>The AAA has an enormous amount of power in its
>relationships with corporations like Hilton. For the
>Hiltons and Marriotts of the world, what matters most is
>maintaining the AAA as a long-term client; they want your
>business year-after-year. They are too smart and savvy to
>risk severing a relationship with a key customer like the
>AAA over a situation like the one in San Francisco. In the
>big picture, $1.2 million is not what is important to
>them; a very long and very profitable relationship with
>the AAA and other academic organizations is more important
>to them in the long run than $1.2 million in the short
>term. Additionally, in a competitive marketplace they
>cannot afford a reputation as a company that sues its
>For an organization whose scholarship and research often
>focuses on power relationships, your organization made a
>decision, in my opinion, that did not take into account
>the power-you have as an organization-in your relationship
>Having said that, we are especially grateful to the AAA
>members, leaders and activists who galvanized support
>among the membership and who lead the effort to convince
>the AAA's leadership that crossing a picket line in SF was
>completely antithetical to everything your organization
>Many people have asked what the AAA can do moving forward
>to support the hotel workers struggle in SF and around the
>country. Given your unique relationship with the Hilton
>Corporation, concrete steps the AAA can take that would
>have a dramatic impact on the struggle of hotel workers in
>this country include:
>· ensuring that your staff has strong "force majeure"
>language in your hotel contracts, to address labor
>disputes. You should never have to decide between the
>risk of litigation and crossing boycott or picket lines.
>We can work with the AAA on suggested ?force majeure?
>· a wholesale reexamination of your relationship with
>Hilton Hotels. In order for there to be some lasting
>impact of your move out of San Francisco, Hilton needs to
>understand that a swap to Atlanta is not where the issue
>ends. It is my understanding that you are scheduled to be
>back at the San Francisco Hilton in 2006 and 2008, but you
>are not contractually obligated beyond that. We have very
>concrete ideas about what you can do with Hilton to have a
>broader impact on the current and long term struggle for
>justice for workers in the hotel industry and we would
>welcome the opportunity to work with all of you on those
>We are working with many other academic organizations
>(Sociologists, Geographers, American Studies and others)
>and progressive groups (women's, civil rights, immigrant
>rights, religious) on a coordinated program to deal with
>the hotel industry. Your organization and others like it
>represent hundreds of millions of dollars in economic
>activity for these hotel corporations. We need to work
>together as a cohesive, progressive movement to affect
>real change in the relationship between these corporations
>and workers in the hotel industry.
>Si Se Puede!
>FYI- for those attending the meeting in Atlanta, the Hyatt
>Regency is currently our only union-hotel in Atlanta.
>Hyatt Regency Atlanta
>265 Peachtree Street North East
>Atlanta, GA 30303
>Phone: (404) 577-1234
>For those of you who want to make a contribution to our
>locked out members in San Francisco, here is the
>Local 2 Solidarity Fund
>UNITE HERE! Local 2
>209 Golden Gate Avenue
>San Francisco, CA 94102
>Strategic Affairs Department
Robert T. O'Brien
AAAUnite Ad Hoc Committee
Department of Anthropology
robrien at temple.edu
"We're changing the world,...freedom is the Almighty's gift to every man and woman in this world. And as the greatest power on the face of the Earth, we have an obligation to help the spread of freedom." GWB on
why God loves an imperialist
"...a really diverse crowd here tonight. The haves, and the have-mores. Some people call you elite. I call you my base." GWB at the Al Smith fundraiser, October 19, 2000
More information about the URBANTH-L